Your numbers look fine. So why do new members vanish?
Overall activity can be mostly your longest-standing members. Look at the newest ones on their own.
By Theo Brandt ·

Look at your newest members on their own, apart from everyone else. Your overall activity figures can look healthy while new people quietly disappear.
Here is why. If most of your members have been with you a long time, they do most of the signing in, the reading and the watching, so they set the overall picture. A weak start for new members gets lost inside that picture. By the time the overall figures move, the people who could have been kept have already gone.
You can separate them in four steps. One: list everyone who joined in the last thirty days. Two: for each person, note whether they did something real in their first week, such as finishing a lesson, joining a call or posting a reply. Three: do the same for the members who joined a month earlier. Four: compare the two lists side by side.
If this month's group did less than last month's, you have found something your overall figures were hiding.
Then look at what the quieter ones had in common. Maybe the first lesson was too long, or the welcome message did not say what to do first.
Change one thing about the first week, such as a short welcome note with a single step, and repeat the same count on the next group. The dashboard tells you about your oldest members. This count tells you about your newest.
