Super Intelligent Foo
Vol. 1, Issue #2 · November 2026The family gathers: Foo meets his two new friends

Picking a niche won't keep members. Showing progress will.

A tight niche gets people in. Staying depends on whether they can see how far they have come.

By Maren Holt ·

A coach with a notepad talks with a client at a table beside a large window, through which a path of colorful stepping stones climbs a hill toward a small house.

Once you have chosen your niche, build a way for members to see their own progress. A narrow audience gets people through the door. It does not tell them they are getting somewhere.

Take a coach who serves online shop owners, nobody else. Her content fits them well. Yet in the third month, a few of them quietly cancel. When she asks, they say the sessions were great. What they could not say was what had changed for them since the first week. Nothing in the experience told them.

The common assumption is that the right niche fixes keeping members. It might help, but it is a different thing from progress, which is personal: how far you have come from where you began.

So think about what a member sees between your calls. If the honest answer is that they get content, that may be the gap. Narrowing your niche further will not fill it.

Here is a small fix. At the start, ask each member for one thing they want to change, in a line. Every few weeks, send the line back with a short question: how far along is it now? Add a place for them to note what they tried and what happened.

Pick the niche, then give people a mirror. The two together are what a coaching membership is made of.