Super Intelligent Foo
Vol. 1, Issue #2 · November 2026The family gathers: Foo meets his two new friends

Happy members still cancel, so watch what they do

A high survey score is not a renewal. Habits are easier to see, and easier to act on, than feelings.

By Theo Brandt ·

A smiling person stands in an open blue doorway holding a heart-shaped card, while an empty red armchair with a closed book beside it sits unused outside.

Watch what members do, not just what they say. A good survey score tells you how someone feels today. Whether they renew depends on whether using you has become a habit.

It is easy to see how the two come apart. A member gives you nine out of ten and means it. Then they sign in twice in six months, finish no lessons and never post in the community. They like you. They have just not built you into their week. When the renewal date comes, they cancel without guilt, because they are not leaving something they use.

The survey said everything was fine. The behavior said otherwise. You were reading only one of them.

Try this in four steps. One: pick the three habits that show a member is getting value, such as signing in, finishing a lesson and replying in the community. Two: list your members who have done none of the three in the last month. Three: sort that list by renewal date, soonest first. Four: write to the first ten, one by one, before their date arrives.

Keep the message short and about them. Ask what they hoped to get from you and offer to help with the first step.

Do this each month. A satisfied member who never shows up is a cancellation that has not happened yet, and you have a few weeks to change that.