Super Intelligent Foo
Vol. 1, Issue #2 · November 2026The family gathers: Foo meets his two new friends

Finishing a course and renewing are the same problem

If members stop renewing, check whether they ever finished. Structure can help more than another bonus.

By Theo Brandt ·

A path winding up a green hill with plain blue and yellow flags beside it, two people walking up it, two more helping each other over a log, and a finish gate with a red ribbon at the top.

A self-paced course has one weakness: nobody is holding anyone to the path. Someone who starts with good intentions can drift away, and it is easy not to notice.

From your side, it can look like a problem of members not coming back. Members stop renewing and upgrades do not land. So you add more lessons and more bonuses, and the cancellations carry on.

Here is another way to see it. A member who does not finish does not get the result they came for. Without the result they have little reason to stay. Not coming back and not finishing may be the same problem, and it starts at the moment someone quietly stops making progress.

Try this in four steps. One: list your lessons in order and count how many members started each one. Two: look for the biggest drop between two lessons. Three: read the lesson before it as a member who has been doing well. Four: add one piece of structure just there, such as a short check-in message, a fixed date for a group call or a small shared task with a deadline.

Do not add more at this stage. Structure means a reason to come back on a particular day, not another thing to get through.

A member who finishes has the result they came for, and a reason to keep going with you. Look at finishing first and the rest may follow.