Super Intelligent Foo
Vol. 1, Issue #2 · November 2026The family gathers: Foo meets his two new friends

Charge what it is worth. But worth to whom?

Value-based pricing is the right start. Your own numbers tell you where your price should land.

By Orla Finch ·

A shopkeeper in a blue apron holds up a blank red price tag between a woman with a basket from a winding country lane and a man with a bicycle from the street.

When someone tells you to charge what your membership is worth, ask yourself what in your own business tells you what it is worth. That is where a price comes from.

Charge by value is good advice. It is also advice any site could be given. It leaves you in a wide field with questions still open: worth to whom, measured how, compared with what?

Look for a signal in your own members. Here are three to try.

The first is when people cancel. If many leave after the third month, ask whether there is enough to do before then. If there is not, a higher price will speed up the problem, not solve it.

The second is whether members move up. If almost nobody ever leaves your cheapest plan, the question is not only whether it is too cheap. It is whether the bigger plan gives them a reason to move.

The third is where members came from. People who arrived by search and people who came from a list you built can read the same content and judge its price very differently, because they arrived knowing different amounts about you.

Pick the signal you can check this week, write down what you find, and let it set your next move. A price chosen that way can be explained to a member, and to you.