# Members share one login. Where do you start?

> A blanket rule treats every member like a suspect. Start with the one thing that would hurt most to lose.

By Theo Brandt. Published 2026-11-11.

You find out some members are sharing their login with people who have not paid. The usual advice is a rule for everyone: limit how many devices can sign in at once, send a reminder about your terms, and hope people are honest.

The trouble is that a rule for everyone lands on your honest members first. It also does not tell you where the real leak is. So start somewhere else: with what you would actually lose.

Here is how, in four steps. One: list your membership levels. Two: next to each, write what it unlocks, such as a course, a private group, a download or a live session. Three: mark which of those would hurt most if a non-member got it free. Four: protect that one first.

Protecting it can be light. You might limit sign-ins on that level only, or put the most valuable item behind a second step, or watch that one level for sign-ins from far-apart places in the same hour. Your honest members on every other level notice nothing.

Leave the rest alone for now. A cheap level that gives away a little is often not worth the friction of policing it. Spend your attention where a leak costs you most, and check again in a month whether it has stopped.
